How do I compare roofing bids?
Direct answer: Line up every bid on the same scope: materials, tear-off layers, underlayment, ice and water shield, ventilation, flashing, decking policy, warranty, timeline, and price. A cheaper bid that skips tear-off, ventilation, or flashing is not the same job. CEVS offers a free first-pass bid review and $125/hour consulting for a deeper second opinion.
Eli’s take
I have spent decades on roofs and in attics. The bids that look closest on the bottom line are often miles apart in scope. I walk the roof and inspect the attic before anyone should treat a number as final — that is how you catch soft decking, poor ventilation, and ice-dam risk before tear-off day. Partner crews I work with typically cover up to about four repair sheets as a max average when issues turn up; that is a planning cue, not a fixed contingency percent for your budget.
Normalize these line items
| Line | What to match across bids |
|---|---|
| Materials | Shingle or metal type and line (e.g. architectural asphalt, Class 4, standing-seam metal). Same product class, not just “metal” vs “asphalt.” |
| Tear-off | How many existing layers are removed? Overlay vs full tear-off changes price and long-term performance. |
| Underlayment | Synthetic vs felt; coverage area. |
| Ice and water shield | Valleys, eaves, and penetrations — especially important in Iowa freeze-thaw. |
| Ventilation | Ridge, soffit, or other intake/exhaust; attic assessment. |
| Flashing | Step, counter, wall, chimney, skylight — new vs reuse. |
| Decking | Who pays for bad sheets found after tear-off? How is it priced per sheet? |
| Warranty | Manufacturer material warranty and workmanship terms, in writing. |
| Timeline | Start window, weather delays, crew size expectations. |
| Price | Total, what is excluded, deposit, and how long the bid stays valid. |
Steps: run a fair comparison
- Get at least two bids written for the same address and the same assumed scope.
- Print or spreadsheet the table above and fill one column per bidder.
- Mark gaps — missing ice and water shield, vague “flashing as needed,” or “decking extra” with no unit price.
- Ask the same follow-ups of every bidder (see FAQ).
- Send the packets for a free first-pass review if you want a second set of eyes before you sign.
What CEVS does (and does not)
- Does: Inspect roofs, siding, windows, and doors; give an honest condition opinion; gather and present bids as one point of contact; free first-pass bid review; consulting at $125/hour for deeper advocacy.
- Does not: Run “our own crews,” act as your project manager (Iowa contractor registration is not in place for that), do insurance-claim work, or position around storm/hail claims.
- Disclosure: Eli can gather bids for you. If he recommends a company he knows or does sales for, he’ll tell you that up front at the time. He can also bring in bids from other roofers so you have a real comparison. Partner companies are not named on this site.
Published CEVS reference floors (not your final price)
Use these only as planning anchors after a site visit sets the real number:
- Architectural asphalt: starting at $500 per square (typical range depends on materials and pitch; can run much higher)
- Class 4 impact-resistant: about $750 per square (calculator default)
- Standing-seam metal: $1,750 per square
- Extra tear-off layer: $98 per square
- Premium options (stone-coated steel, slate, shake, PVC/rubber): ask for a written range — treat them as premium materials; exact public ranges are confirmed at quote time
- Bid comparison / first-pass review: free
- Consulting: $125/hour
Local Iowa note
Des Moines requires a building permit for every roof-covering replacement starting January 1, 2027 (Ord. 16,568). Through the end of 2026, confirm the city’s current path for your job. Suburbs write their own rules. Build permit fees and inspection timing into the comparison so one bid does not hide costs another includes. See Do I need a permit to replace my roof in Des Moines?.
FAQ
Should I pick the lowest bid?
Only after the scopes match. The lowest number often drops tear-off, ventilation, or flashing. Compare equal work first, then price.
How much contingency should I hold for bad decking?
CEVS does not publish a fixed percent. Eli walks the roof and inspects the attic to reduce surprises. When issues are found, partner crews typically cover up to about four repair sheets as a max average — ask each bidder how extra sheets are priced and who decides.
Will CEVS recommend a specific roofing company?
Eli can gather bids, including from companies he knows or does sales for — and he will tell you that up front if so. He can also bring in other roofers for a real comparison. No referral fees. Partner names stay off the public site.
Does a free bid review mean you will install my roof?
No. CEVS is consulting and mediation. Installation, if you choose a company Eli sells for, is disclosed at the time and contracted with that company — not as “CEVS crews.”
What about financing?
Educational only on the site: cash, HELOC/home equity, personal loan, or financing through a lender at a company you hire. Eli is a registered agent/sales rep through companies he works with; lender and company names are not listed here. Read APR, fees, and deferred-interest terms before you sign anything.
Next step
Email your bids to eli@cevs-consult.com for a free first-pass review, or book a 90-minute site visit. Visits run 7 days a week, max two per day, about 3.5 hours including drive time, usually with 24 hours notice (emergencies may cost extra). Service area: about 150 miles of Dexter, Iowa — Waukee and Adel included; willing to travel.
Office: (515) 498-7602
